Why this check exists.

On October 13, 2026, multiple PSA customer orders were stolen from a FedEx carrier truck after pickup at PSA’s Santa Ana, California facility. The first stolen list that circulated — 383 serialized cards — was only an early, partial list. PSA has now published the complete list: 6,451 stolen items, with cert numbers and, for serialized cards, serial numbers. Every stolen cert has been deactivated, and PSA has shared the full list with marketplace sellers, auction houses, and digital commerce platforms, which are actively monitoring for these items. The FBI and the Santa Ana Police Department are investigating.

The check, step by step.

Step 1 — Find the cert number. It is printed on the PSA label at the top of the slab. On a serialized card, note the serial number as well.

Step 2 — Open PSA’s published list. PSA’s theft update carries the complete stolen-item list: PSA — Stolen PSA Orders: What We’re Doing and How You Can Help. The list is public and searchable, no login required.

Step 3 — Search the cert number. Search the list for the cert number on the label — and, on a serialized card, the serial number too. You can also run the cert through PSA’s cert lookup: a stolen cert returns a deactivation notice.

Step 4 — If it matches, walk away. A cert on the list, or a lookup that shows the cert as deactivated, means that item was stolen. Do not buy it, whatever the price. If you see one listed for sale, PSA asks that you report it — contacts are in PSA’s update, including the FBI’s Los Angeles office at +1 310-477-6565 and the Santa Ana Police Department at +1 714-245-8345.

If your order was stolen.

Per PSA’s published terms: grading fees for impacted orders were refunded in full, separate from and not reducing item compensation. Orders shipped on PSA’s return label are insured at fair market value, capped at the declared Maximum Insured Value, and payments are already going out. Orders shipped on your own label are worked case by case by a dedicated PSA team. Accepting compensation does not end recovery: if your item is recovered later, you choose — keep the compensation or take the item back.

How many items were stolen?

PSA’s complete published list covers 6,451 stolen items. The 383 figure that circulated first was an early, partial list of serialized cards only.

What happens if I search a stolen cert?

Every stolen certification number has been deactivated. The cert appears on PSA’s published stolen list, and PSA’s cert lookup returns a deactivation notice for it.

Where is PSA’s stolen list?

Linked from PSA’s theft update: psacard.com — Stolen PSA Orders. It is public and searchable.

Are sellers and auction houses watching for these items?

Yes. PSA shared the full list with marketplace sellers, auction houses, and digital commerce platforms, which are actively monitoring.

Open PSA’s stolen list ↗ Watch the breakdown →

Methodology

Sources for this guide.

Every fact on this page comes from PSA’s own theft update article, read in full on October 23, 2026. No third-party figures are used; PSA publishes no total value for the theft, so none is stated here.

Read our full methodology →