The Cardboard Signal Standard.

Five rules, no exceptions. This is the public editorial standard every Cardboard Signal video is held to.

  1. Verified sales only. We report prices only from completed, verifiable sales — always with the venue and the date. If a sale can’t be confirmed, it doesn’t go on screen.
  2. Exact-match comps only. Same set, same card, same parallel or variation, same grade. A similar card is not a comp. Close doesn’t count.
  3. Asking ≠ sold. A listing price is not a sale price, and we never blur the two. Every number we show is labeled for what it actually is.
  4. No hype without evidence. Every claim carries its receipt. If we say a card sold, you’ll see where, when, and for how much.
  5. No guessing, no filling gaps.

What we verify.

Auction results. Hammer price, buyer’s premium, venue, and date. We report the all-in price and say exactly what’s included — a headline number without the premium attached is a different number.

Sold listings. Completed sales only. On eBay, the price shown on a Best Offer sale is the list price, not what the buyer paid — we check the accepted price or we don’t publish the number.

Grading information. Grade, grader, and certification details read off the actual slab — never assumed from a listing title. A photo of the wrong grade is a brand violation, not a rounding error.

Our labels.

What we never do.

  • Price predictions. We report what happened, not what’s next. Past results don’t predict future ones.
  • Hype language. No “moon,” no “explode,” no manufactured urgency. Numbers don’t need adjectives.
  • Unsupported rankings. A “most expensive” claim names the exact category, venue set, and date range — or we don’t make it.
  • Asking prices as sold prices. A listing is an invitation, not a transaction.

Spotted an error?

We correct and note it. Email the sale, the page, and what’s wrong.

[email protected]