The Cardboard Signal Standard.
Five rules, no exceptions. This is the public editorial standard every Cardboard Signal video is held to.
- Verified sales only. We report prices only from completed, verifiable sales — always with the venue and the date. If a sale can’t be confirmed, it doesn’t go on screen.
- Exact-match comps only. Same set, same card, same parallel or variation, same grade. A similar card is not a comp. Close doesn’t count.
- Asking ≠ sold. A listing price is not a sale price, and we never blur the two. Every number we show is labeled for what it actually is.
- No hype without evidence. Every claim carries its receipt. If we say a card sold, you’ll see where, when, and for how much.
- No guessing, no filling gaps.
What we verify.
Auction results. Hammer price, buyer’s premium, venue, and date. We report the all-in price and say exactly what’s included — a headline number without the premium attached is a different number.
Sold listings. Completed sales only. On eBay, the price shown on a Best Offer sale is the list price, not what the buyer paid — we check the accepted price or we don’t publish the number.
Grading information. Grade, grader, and certification details read off the actual slab — never assumed from a listing title. A photo of the wrong grade is a brand violation, not a rounding error.
Our labels.
What we never do.
- Price predictions. We report what happened, not what’s next. Past results don’t predict future ones.
- Hype language. No “moon,” no “explode,” no manufactured urgency. Numbers don’t need adjectives.
- Unsupported rankings. A “most expensive” claim names the exact category, venue set, and date range — or we don’t make it.
- Asking prices as sold prices. A listing is an invitation, not a transaction.
Spotted an error?
We correct and note it. Email the sale, the page, and what’s wrong.
[email protected]