What happened.

The card is the 2006 Pokémon EX Holon Phantoms Gold Star #102 Gyarados-Holo — the shiny red Gyarados, illustrated by Masakazu Fukuda — in PSA 10. The listing’s own Item Specifics put the PSA 10 population at 37. On October 31, 2026, the copy graded under cert 42024061 sold on eBay (item 307257381271) out of PSA’s own eBay account, the PSA Vault store: listed at $885,000 as a fixed price with Best Offer, and sold on an accepted offer of $450,000. It is an accepted offer, not an auction result and not a full-price sale — the distinction matters, and it is how the story shipped on November 9, 2026 as our Short “This Gyarados Went From $98,888 to a $450,000 Accepted Offer.” PSA announced the sale on November 6, 2026 through its eBay store.

What makes the print checkable is the cert. Cert 42024061 is the same physical slab that sold on eBay for $98,888 on January 7, 2026 — read from the completed listing’s Item Specifics and from the slab label in its photo. The card’s recorded PSA 10 history runs: $11,110 (eBay, March 2021), $18,000 (eBay, November 2024), $18,247 (eBay, March 2025), $98,888 (eBay, January 7, 2026 — this same cert), $91,500 at Goldin (March 9, 2026), $80,520 at Goldin (April 20, 2026), and then $450,000 on the October 31 accepted offer. Through spring, the price line was falling. October repriced the same slab at more than four times the card’s previous record.

Why it matters.

A record print is not automatically a new market price, and this one shows why. The sale itself is confirmed at the listing level — price, date, format, seller, and the sold copy’s cert all read directly off the completed listing, with CardTrack’s sales ledger and PokemonCardValue carrying the same $450,000 / October 31 print. But the trackers do not price the card off it: CardTrack still prints its headline PSA 10 market price as $80,520 and excludes the $450,000 from its price index, and PriceCharting shows no PSA 10 sales data for the card at all (its figure is a labeled estimate). One accepted offer, however well documented, is one buyer and one seller agreeing — at 51% of the ask.

Payment settlement is the one element no public source can confirm for an eBay sale, this one included. What is confirmed is the agreement and the identity of the copy: the January buyer’s slab came back nine months later and took $450,000. Whether the next copy to sell follows it is the open question this record leaves behind.

Methodology

How this was verified.

The completed eBay listing (item 307257381271) was opened and read directly on November 7, 2026: price, date, format, seller, and the sold copy’s cert (42024061) come from the listing itself, with the cert confirmed in both the Item Specifics and the slab label in the listing photo. The January 2026 $98,888 sale of the same cert and the wider PSA 10 sale history come from CardTrack’s cert-level sales ledger, cross-checked against Goldin lot reporting for the two auction results and PokemonCardValue’s eBay-derived records. Payment settlement cannot be confirmed from public sources for any eBay sale and is labeled unconfirmed here. Watch the breakdown: our Gyarados Gold Star Short.

Read our full methodology →

Sources:
  • eBay — completed listing, item 307257381271 (read November 7, 2026)
  • CardTrack — cert-level sales ledger, EX Holon Phantoms Gyarados #102 PSA 10
  • Goldin Auctions — March 9 and April 20, 2026 lot results
  • PSA — sale announcement via its eBay store (November 6, 2026)
  • Cardboard Signal — Short, “This Gyarados Went From $98,888 to a $450,000 Accepted Offer” (November 9, 2026)
Watch on YouTube ↗ All market moves