What happened.
On September 4, 2026, Sullivan’s Debut Patch Auto 1/1 sold at Alt for $324,000. That is the biggest MLS card sale ever recorded, a U.S. national team player record (it passed Christian Pulisic’s $113,460 mark), and 3.6× the previous record.
Then the soccer caught up. On October 3, against Mexico, Sullivan scored — 17 years, 5 days old, the youngest goal-scorer in USMNT history. The $324,000 wasn’t paid for what he had done. It was paid for what the market believed was coming.
The record pulled his whole market with it: his /99 autographs climbed from $95 earlier this year to $1,100 on October 6.
Why it matters.
Prospect pricing is the purest form of the hobby’s forward market: a 17-year-old’s 1/1 priced like an established star’s grail, before the milestone that would justify it. This time the milestone arrived a month later — which will embolden the next prospect market, whether or not the next player scores.
Methodology
How this price was verified.
The $324,000 Alt result (September 4, 2026) and its record context are as reported by Sports Illustrated and Heavy, corroborated by Alt’s own record-sale announcement. The /99 autograph figures ($95 earlier this year; $1,100 on October 6) are from Sports Illustrated’s market reporting and tracked sales. Watch the breakdown: our Short on the sale.
Spotted an error? Email [email protected] — we correct and note it.
- Alt — record-sale announcement (September 2026)
- Sports Illustrated; Heavy — sale and market reporting
- Cardboard Signal — Short, October 15, 2026
Market moves, in your inbox.
Every Market Move, delivered the day it publishes — verified sales, why they matter, and what they mean for collectors. No spam, ever.