The pairs.

Measurement window for every pair: July 16 – November 15, 2026 (eBay completed sales, via CardSight). CGC figures are CGC Gem Mint 10 only — see the methodology note on Pristine.

Card (exact match)PSA 10 medianCGC 10 medianMedian difference
Gengar VMAX
2021 Fusion Strike #157 Alt Art
$229.99
n = 362
$116.28
n = 26
$113.71
Charizard VMAX
2020 Darkness Ablaze #20
$152.50
n = 219
$99.99
n = 13
$52.51
Umbreon VMAX
2021 Evolving Skies #215 Alt Art
$4,150.00
n = 445
$3,000.00
n = 18
$1,150.00
Cooper Flagg
2025 Topps Chrome #251 Base
$305.00
n = 428
$102.50
n = 19
$202.50
Victor Wembanyama
2023 Panini Prizm #136 Base
$385.00
n = 542
$171.50
n = 13
$213.50

Read it pair by pair. Gengar VMAX’s CGC 10 median sits $113.71 under its PSA 10 median; Cooper Flagg’s sits $202.50 under. Umbreon VMAX — the most expensive pair here — shows the largest dollar gap at $1,150.00, on a deep PSA sample (n = 445) against a thin CGC one (n = 18). Three CGC sides added nothing this cycle — Charizard VMAX (n = 13), Umbreon VMAX (n = 18), and Wembanyama (n = 13) — while Gengar’s CGC side added two sales (n = 26) and Flagg’s added one (n = 19). Anyone quoting you one universal percentage for “CGC versus PSA” is averaging away the only part that matters: the specific card.

Why the spread exists.

A grade is a grade, but a slab is also a market: buyer demand, population, and resale liquidity differ by grading company, and those differences price in at sale time. This page does not explain any single pair’s gap — it documents the gaps, from completed sales, so the next claim about them can be checked against receipts.

See the Signal Index ↗ All market moves