The pairs.
Measurement window for every pair: July 16 – November 15, 2026 (eBay completed sales, via CardSight). CGC figures are CGC Gem Mint 10 only — see the methodology note on Pristine.
| Card (exact match) | PSA 10 median | CGC 10 median | Median difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gengar VMAX 2021 Fusion Strike #157 Alt Art | $229.99 n = 362 | $116.28 n = 26 | $113.71 |
| Charizard VMAX 2020 Darkness Ablaze #20 | $152.50 n = 219 | $99.99 n = 13 | $52.51 |
| Umbreon VMAX 2021 Evolving Skies #215 Alt Art | $4,150.00 n = 445 | $3,000.00 n = 18 | $1,150.00 |
| Cooper Flagg 2025 Topps Chrome #251 Base | $305.00 n = 428 | $102.50 n = 19 | $202.50 |
| Victor Wembanyama 2023 Panini Prizm #136 Base | $385.00 n = 542 | $171.50 n = 13 | $213.50 |
Read it pair by pair. Gengar VMAX’s CGC 10 median sits $113.71 under its PSA 10 median; Cooper Flagg’s sits $202.50 under. Umbreon VMAX — the most expensive pair here — shows the largest dollar gap at $1,150.00, on a deep PSA sample (n = 445) against a thin CGC one (n = 18). Three CGC sides added nothing this cycle — Charizard VMAX (n = 13), Umbreon VMAX (n = 18), and Wembanyama (n = 13) — while Gengar’s CGC side added two sales (n = 26) and Flagg’s added one (n = 19). Anyone quoting you one universal percentage for “CGC versus PSA” is averaging away the only part that matters: the specific card.
Why the spread exists.
A grade is a grade, but a slab is also a market: buyer demand, population, and resale liquidity differ by grading company, and those differences price in at sale time. This page does not explain any single pair’s gap — it documents the gaps, from completed sales, so the next claim about them can be checked against receipts.
Get the weekly Signal Index update by email
The Signal Index snapshot, refreshed weekly — verified sales, medians, and what moved. Email field only; nothing else collected.